Accounts of His Martyrdom
The surviving notices of Athenodorus are brief hagiographic entries rather than a full biography. They agree on the central episode: condemned to death, he could not be killed by the means appointed. The fire set to burn him would not light, and the executioner who approached to behead him fell down, leaving the sentence unfulfilled. While another method of execution was being sought, the saint is said to have prayed and died.
The synaxarion relates that miracles accompanied his suffering and that these signs converted many of the pagans who witnessed them. The figure named as his judge is the governor Eleusius; the wider persecution is associated by several sources with the emperor Diocletian and dated to about the year 304. The saint's own record, however, leaves his era and century unspecified.